What kind of whiskey should I use for a Manhattan cocktail?

Traditionally rye whiskey is preferred for its spicy character. Bourbon works too if you prefer a softer, sweeter note. Canadian or blended whiskeys are sometimes used, especially historically when rye was not available.

Is it okay to use bourbon instead of rye for my Manhattan cocktail?

Absolutely. Bourbon is a widely accepted alternative. The result will be slightly sweeter and less peppery, still delicious.

Why must I stir a Manhattan cocktail instead of shaking it?

Stirring preserves the clarity and silky texture of the cocktail. Shaking introduces air bubbles and tiny ice chips that cloud the drink and over-dilute it. The Manhattan is a spirit-forward cocktail meant to showcase the whiskey's character, and stirring achieves the right dilution and temperature while maintaining the proper texture.

Can I skip the cherry garnish for my Manhattan?

Yes. Some purists even prefer a simple twist of orange peel, which adds a subtle citrus aroma and lets the whiskey-vermouth-bitters interplay shine.

What is the difference between a Manhattan cocktail and a [Rob Roy](/en/articles/Rob%20Roy.html) cocktail?

The main difference is whiskey choice. A [Rob Roy](/en/articles/Rob%20Roy.html) uses Scotch whisky instead of rye or bourbon. Other than that, proportions and method are very similar.

Can I batch Manhattan cocktails for a party?

Absolutely, Manhattans are excellent for batching. Simply multiply the recipe by the number of servings you need, add about 25% water to account for dilution from stirring, and store in the refrigerator. When ready to serve, pour directly into chilled glasses and garnish. Your guests will think you're a cocktail wizard.

Can I make a Manhattan cocktail without fancy equipment?

Yes! While a mixing glass, bar spoon, and strainer make the job easier, you can improvise. Use any sturdy glass for mixing, a regular spoon for stirring, and strain through a small mesh strainer or even a fork held against the rim of your glass. The most important elements are quality ingredients, proper dilution through stirring, and a cold serving glass. Technique and tools help, but passion and good ingredients matter most.

How strong is a Manhattan compared to other cocktails?

Manhattan is considered a relatively strong cocktail compared with many other drinks, it usually has an alcohol by volume (ABV) of about 25-30%. Is is comparable to other spirit-forward cocktails like the [Negroni](/en/articles/Negroni.html) or [Old Fashioned](/en/articles/Old%20Fashioned.html). Sip slowly and savor responsibly!

The Manhattan Cocktail: A Drink That Makes Wall Street Elites Drop Their Spreadsheets 🍸

Sophia

Posted on November 7, 2024

Classic Bitter Sweet Herbaceous Aperitif Digestif Nightcap Up Stirred Rye Whiskey Bourbon